Mortality, Work and Migration. A Consideration of Age-specific Mortality from Tuberculosis in Scotland, 1861-1901
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.51964/hlcs9331Keywords:
Urban-rural migration, Tuberculosis, Scotland, Return migration, Mortality, Cause of deathAbstract
This paper provides an examination into some of the most enduring debates regarding tuberculosis mortality during the nineteenth century: those related to gender, geographic and temporal variations. We use populations reconstructed from individual census and civil register data for the period 1861 to 1901, comparing a growing urban area with a declining rural area, both with around 20,000 inhabitants in 1861. Our analysis shows that among young adults tuberculosis was linked to excess female mortality in the urban area and excess male mortality in the rural area. We demonstrate that in the town textile workers of both genders had particularly high mortality from tuberculosis, and that the only reason for higher overall female mortality was the predominance of young women in the textile labour force. We show that the age and gender-specific pattern of mortality in the rural area is consistent with higher male than female out-migration together with return migration of those who had contracted the disease elsewhere and needed care during their lengthy illness. We argue that the observed patterns are difficult to reconcile with the ‘bargaining-nutrition’ account of gendered patterns in tuberculosis mortality, and that they provide little support for nutrition as a key influence on the disease. However, our findings do reinforce Andrew Hinde’s recent argument that geographical patterns in sex-specific tuberculosis mortality rates were largely determined by migration patterns, and we discuss the implications of this for our understanding of the decline of the disease over the late nineteenth century.
Downloads
References
Alter, G.C., Manfredini, M., & Nystedt, P. (2004). Gender differences in mortality. In T. Bengtsson, C. Campbell, & J. Lee (Eds.), Life under pressure: Mortality and living standards in Europe and Asia, 1700-1900 (pp. 173-208). Cambridge, MA: MIT University Press.
Anderson, M. (1990). The social implications of demographic change. In F.M.L Thompson (Ed.), The Cambridge social history of Britain 1750-1950, Volume 2: People and their environment (pp. 1-70). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. doi: 10.1017/CHOL9780521257893
Boyle, P., & Norman, P. (2009). Migration and health. In T. Brown, S. McLafferty, & G. Moon (Eds.), A companion to health and medical geography (pp. 346-375). Oxford, UK: Wiley-Blackwell. doi: 10.1002/9781444314762.ch19
British Parliamentary Papers (1889). Cotton cloth factories: a bill [as amended in committee] to make further provision for the regulation of cotton cloth factories. 19th century House of Commons Sessional Papers, Bills & Acts [l. 421].
Cegielski, J., & McMurray, D. (2004). The relationship between malnutrition and tuberculosis: Evidence from studies in humans and experimental animals. International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 8, 286–298.
Cronje, G. (1984). Tuberculosis and mortality decline in England and Wales 1851-1910. In R. Woods, & J. Woodward (Eds.), Urban disease and mortality in nineteenth century England and Wales (pp. 79-101). London: Batsford.
Davenport, R.J. (2013). Year of birth effects in the historical decline of tuberculosis mortality: A reconsideration. PLoS ONE, 8(12): e81797. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0081797
Devos, I. (1996). La régionalisation de la surmortalité des jeunes filles en Belgique entre 1890 et 1910. Annales de démographie historique, 1996, 375-407. doi: 10.3406/adh.1996.1928
Eggerickx, T., & Tabutin, D. (1994). La surmortalité des filles en Belgique vers 1890: Une approche régionale. Population, 49(3), 657-683. doi: 10.2307/1533962
Farr, W. (1864). Letter to the Registrar-General on the mortality in registration districts of England during the ten years 1850-60. Supplement to the twenty fifth annual report of the Registrar General of Births, Deaths and Marriages in England. London: HMSO, xxv.
Ferrie, J. (2003). The rich and the dead. Socioeconomic status and mortality in the United States, 1850-1860. In D.L. Costa (Ed.), Health and labor force participation over the lifecycle: evidence from the past (pp. 11-50). Chicago: University of Chicago. Retrieved from https://www.nber.org/chapters/c9627.pdf
Galley, C., & Reid, A. (2014). Maternal mortality. Local Population Studies, 93, 68-78. Available from http://www.localpopulationstudies.org.uk/journal.htm
Ginsburg, C., Bocquier, P., Beguy, D., Afolabi, S., Augusto, O., Derra, K., … Collinson, M. (2016). Healthy or unhealthy migrants? Identifying internal migration effects on mortality in Africa using health and demographic surveillance systems of the INDEPTH network. Social Science and Medicine, 164, 59-73. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2016.06.035
Greenlees, J. (2005). ‘Stop kissing and steaming!’: Tuberculosis and the occupational health movement in the Massachusetts and Lancashire cotton weaving industries, 1870-1918. Urban History, 32(2), 223-246. doi: 10.1017/S0963926805002981
Guha, S. (1994). The importance of social intervention in England’s mortality decline: The evidence reviewed. Social History of Medicine, 7(1), 89–113. doi: 10.1093/shm/7.1.89
Gupta, K., Gupta, R., Atreja, A., Verma, M., & Vishvkarma, S. (2009). Tuberculosis and nutrition. Lung India: Official Organ of Indian Chest Society, 26(1), 9-16. doi: 10.4103/0970-2113.45198
Harris, B. (2004). Public health, nutrition, and the decline of mortality: The McKeown thesis revisited. Social History of Medicine, 17(3), 379-407. doi: 10.1093/shm/17.3.379
Hinde, A. (2015). Sex differentials in phthisis mortality in England and Wales, 1861-1870. The History of the Family, 20(3), 1-27. doi: 10.1080/1081602X.2015.1051077
Humphries, J. (1991). ‘Bread and a pennyworth of treacle’: Excess female mortality in England in the 1840s. Cambridge Journal of Economics, 15, 451-473. doi: 10.1093/oxfordjournals.cje.a035183
Janssens, A., Messelinka, M., & Need, A. (2010). Faulty genes or faulty parents? Gender, family and survival in early and late childhood in the Netherlands, 1860-1900. The History of the Family, 15, 99-108. doi: 10.1016/j.hisfam.2010.01.005
Johansson, S.R. (1996). Excess female mortality: Constructing survival during development in Meiji Japan and Victorian England. In A. Digby, & J. Stewart (Eds.), Gender, health and welfare (pp. 32-66). London: Routledge.
Levira, F., Todd, J., & Masanja, H. (2014). Coming home to die? The association between migration and mortality in rural Tanzania before and after ART scale-up. Global Health Action, 7, 229-256. doi: 10.3402/gha.v7.22956
McKeown, T. (1976). The modern rise of population. London: Hodder & Stoughton.
McNay, K., Humphries, J., & Klasen, S. (2005). Excess female mortality in nineteenth-century England and Wales: A regional analysis. Social Science History, 29, 649-681. doi: 10.1017/S0145553200013341
Newsholme, A. (1906). An inquiry into the principal causes of the reduction in the death-rate from phthisis during the last forty years, with special reference to the segregation of phthisical patients in general institutions. Journal of Hygiene Cambridge, 6, 304-384. Retrieved from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2236177/pdf/jhyg00301-0079.pdf
Padiak, J. (2009). Diachronic analysis of cause-of-death terminology: The case of tuberculosis. Social Science History, 33, 341-356. doi: 10.1017/S0145553200011019
Pooley, M., & Pooley, C. (1984). Health, society and environment in nineteenth-century Manchester. In R. Woods, & J. Woodward (Eds.), Urban disease and mortality in nineteenth century England and Wales (pp. 148-175). London: Batsford.
Registrar-General of births, deaths and marriages in Scotland (1875). Seventeenth detailed annual report … (abstracts of 1871). Edinburgh: HMSO. Cd. 1299, xi.
Reid, A., Davies, R., & Garrett, E. (2006). Nineteenth century Scottish demography from linked censuses and civil registers: A ‘sets of related individuals’ approach. History & Computing, 14, 61-86. doi: 10.3366/hac.2002.14.1-2.61
Reid, A., & Garrett, E. (2012). Doctors and the causes of neonatal death in nineteenth century Scotland. Annales de Demographie Historique, 123, 149-179. doi: 10.3917/adh.123.0149
Reid, A., & Garrett, E. (2018). Medical provision and urban-rural differences in maternal mortality in late nineteenth century Scotland. Social Science and Medicine, 201, 35-43. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2018.01.028
Reid, A., Garrett, E., Dibben, C., & Williamson, L. (2015). ‘A confession of ignorance’: Deaths from old age and deciphering cause of death statistics in Scotland 1855-1949. The History of the Family, 20, 320-344. doi: 10.1080/1081602X.2014.1001768
Reid, A., Garrett, E., Williamson, L., & Dibben, C. (2016). A century of deaths, Scotland 1855-1955: A view from the civil registers. In P. Jupp (Ed.), Death in Modern Scotland (pp. 131-160). Oxford: Peter Lang.
Szreter, S. (1988). The Importance of social intervention in Britain’s mortality decline c. 1850–1914: A reinterpretation of the role of public health. Social History of Medicine, 1, 1-38. Retrieved from https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/a350/8f97eff18b8cffb5ccd8c87feda108895c58.pdf
Ruggles, S. (1992). Migration, marriage, and mortality: Correcting sources of bias in English family reconstitutions. Population Studies, 46, 507-522. doi: 10.1080/0032472031000146486
Tabutin, D., & Willems, M. (1998). Differential mortality by sex from birth to adolescence: The historical experience of the west (1750-1930). In United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs Population Division, Too young to die: genes or gender? (pp. 17-52). New York: United Nations.
Vögele, J. (1998). Urban mortality change in England and Germany, 1870-1913. Liverpool: Liverpool University Press.
Welton, T.A. (1871). On the effect of migrations in disturbing local rates of mortality, as exemplified in the Statistics of London and the surrounding country, for the years 1851-1860. Journal of the Institute of Actuaries and Assurance Magazine, 16(3), 153-186.
Wilson, L.G. (2005). Commentary: Medicine, population and tuberculosis. International Journal of Epidemiology, 334, 521-524.
Woods, R., & Shelton, N. (1997). An Atlas of Victorian Mortality. Liverpool: Liverpool University Press.
Woods, R., & Shelton, N. (2000). Disease environments in Victorian England and Wales. Historical Methods, 33, 73-82. doi: 10.1080/01615440009598951
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
How to Cite
